Categories
Shared Links - Audio Posts

Antibody tests can’t give answers you want about COVID-19 immunity


Michael_Novakhov
shared this story
.

b’

A health care worker administers a dose of the Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 Vaccine at a mass vaccination site at The Forum arena in Inglewood, Calif., on Feb. 26, 2021.

A health care worker administers a dose of the Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 Vaccine at a mass vaccination site at The Forum arena in Inglewood, Calif., on Feb. 26, 2021. (Eric Thayer/Bloomberg)

Talk of the need for coronavirus booster shots has prompted many Americans to seek antibody tests.n

In most cases, however, getting an antibody test to determine immunity is a fool’s errand, infectious-disease doctors agree. The tests for antibodies, also known as serology tests, do not provide the answers that most people are seeking.n

Both the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and the Food and Drug Administration advise against using antibody tests to determine one’s level of immunity against COVID-19, the disease caused by the coronavirus. So does the Infectious Disease Society of America, which represents infectious-disease specialists.n

n

While some states, including Maryland and South Carolina, are conducting targeted antibody testing for specific purposes, no state is promoting the tests’ use for residents to determine whether they have sufficient immunity or need a booster shot.n

The tests might indicate the presence or even the level of coronavirus-fighting antibodies in the bloodstream, but scientists don’t yet know what number of antibodies provide protection from COVID-19. Antibodies are protein molecules the immune system produces to neutralize viruses or bacteria that have entered the body.n

Antibody levels do help health-care providers establish whether a patient has immunity against other, more familiar infectious diseases, such as measles and hepatitis A and B. But doctors say our relatively short experience with COVID-19 hasn’t yet provided the same information.n

“Because our journey is so young, we don’t yet know what value means immunity,” said Mary Hopkins, associate program director of the Infectious Disease Fellowship Program at Tufts Medical Center.n

Testing for coronavirus antibodies has some benefits xe2x80x94 especially for determining whether someone with COVID-like symptoms had an earlier, undetected COVID-19 infection xe2x80x94 but not for the reasons many are seeking the tests.

“Doctors are ordering antibody tests for people who are worried about waning immunity, but I see that as problematic,” said Alan Wells, medical director of clinical labs at the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center. “For a normal person, knowing your level eight months later (after their initial vaccine dosages) is of relatively little value.”n

In general, the more antibodies, the better, Wells said. But even with a low level of antibodies months after exposure or receiving a vaccine, the body can mount a stout defense against the virus by generating new antibodies in response to a fresh infection. “There is more to your immune response than antibody levels,” Wells said.n

Wells said his hospital, like others, has had a big increase in requests for antibody tests in recent weeks, although he recommends to his colleagues that they use them judiciously.n

Another problem with coronavirus antibody tests, doctors say, is that they are not standardized, so values associated with antibody tests in one version might not be the same as another.n

Some states perform antibody testing on a targeted basis. In South Carolina, the Department of Health and Environmental Control conducts sample antibody testing for vaccinated people to correlate antibody levels with episodes of reinfections or breakthrough cases, said Derrek Asberry, a spokesperson for the department.n

n

Maryland has done antibody testing on more than 500 nursing home residents and determined that 50% of them showed declining antibodies over time. On the basis of those tests, Gov. Larry Hogan ordered boosters for all older Marylanders living in congregate housing.n

Hopkins said large-scale antibody testing eventually should help to determine what antibody levels would provide coronavirus immunity. n

“It would be wonderful and important if you could test every month 5,000 patients 60 years and older and find out who gets reinfections or infections for the first time and see if there is a correlation,” she said. “If you found infections and could say those people had antibodies below 200, that would be helpful.”n

Some antibody tests are able to assign a numerical value to an individual’s antibody levels, although the numbers are not uniform from one manufacturer’s test to another. The level above which a person can be considered to have sufficient immunity is unknown.n

In Kentucky, the state Senate passed a resolution in September that would have enabled residents to substitute an antibody test for proof of vaccination. The resolution proposed that an individual with antibodies at a level above the 20th percentile of the immunized population should be recognized as having protection equal to that of a fully immunized individual. The measure died when the state House didn’t take it up before the special session ended in September.n

Doctors interviewed for this story said that without knowing what level of antibodies provides immunity or the parameters xe2x80x94 especially the timing xe2x80x94 of testing vaccinated people, such a measure may not provide the assurance its sponsors suggested. But Wells added that the idea is not without merit, because higher levels of antibodies do correlate with fewer hospitalizations and deaths.

Thomas Denny, chief operating officer at Duke University School of Medicine’s Human Vaccine Institute, however, said the resolution’s demise was probably a positive development.n

“Given how few labs can do this test and the issues of test validation, it’s good that this bill died,” he wrote in an email. “Also, I would need to go review data in the literature but not sure their stated criteria makes sense.”n

Antibody testing can determine whether someone has been exposed to coronavirus or has received any of the vaccines used against the virus. Some tests detect antibodies created in either case. Others only detect antibodies that are generated by exposure.n

Those tests are different from the PCR (polymerase chain reaction) tests most often used to determine whether someone has the virus. A PCR test detects genetic material present in the coronavirus.n

From early in the pandemic, public health agencies and other medical organizations used PCR tests or antigen tests, which detect certain proteins in the virus and are cheaper and faster though less reliable than PCR tests, as the main tool for diagnosing people with the virus.n

Health-care workers didn’t generally use antibody tests because, as Elitza Theel, an expert in serologic testing at the Mayo Clinic, an academic research center, said, “It takes a good one or two weeks after infection to get a detectable level of antibodies.n

“You don’t want to rely on an antibody test because you will miss people who are acutely affected.”n

Hopkins said that antibody tests are useful for patients suspected of having long COVID-19, the lingering severe symptoms that affect some people months after their first exposure to the virus. PCR tests only detect the virus in its initial phase, in the first two weeks or so.n

If someone with COVID-19 doesn’t get a PCR test in that time, the best way to determine exposure later is with an antibody test, even months after contact with the virus, Hopkins said. “When I see a patient in my clinic who’s short of breath or has mysterious aches, I give them an antibody test to see if it’s long COVID.”n

Doctors say antibody testing also can be useful in determining whether individuals, especially nursing home residents, developed antibodies after they were vaccinated. If not, they could be considered good candidates for infusion with monoclonal antibodies to mimic antibodies produced by the immune system.n

Antibody testing also benefits immunocompromised patients, such as those undergoing cancer treatment, Denny said. “We can test those individuals and show their levels are much lower than the general population and give them a boost and test them again and see if their numbers go up,” he said.n

Still, doctors say, healthy people should be reassured that the human immune system remembers what to do in the face of a new risk.n

Even as the initial antibodies decline after a coronavirus infection or vaccine, the memory cells store information about the original attack, react to a renewed threat and begin to stimulate the body to resume its defense, including by generating a whole new army of antibodies.n

People “shouldn’t freak out” if they learn their coronavirus antibodies have declined over time, Theel said.n

“Memory immunity remains strong. That’s what we need to underscore to the public.”n

This report is a product of Stateline, an initiative of the Pew Charitable Trusts.

Subscribe to Stars and Stripes

Just 99c a week!Subscribe

Sponsored Content

No matter who you’re traveling with, it’s bound to be a real vacation.

Categories
The News And Times Blog

The News And Times Blog Review – 8:59 AM 10/17/2021

from Michael Novakhov on Inoreader

8:59 AM 10/17/2021 – Tweets Review: @MavkaSlavka Putin is sending his constituents into a Covid nightmare. Sputnik has come crashing down to earth.
Post Link – 8:59 AM 10/17/20214h  Tweets by ‎@mikenov Michael Novakhov RetweetedMavka Slavka@MavkaSlavkaPutin is sending his constituents into a Covid nightmare. Sputnik has come crashing down to earth. Michael Novakhov RetweetedFamilyMinded@FamilyMindedcomState-By-State Look at America’s Richest Families Who’s the Richest Family in Each State?www.familyminded.comSep…
 

UK Police are describing the murder of a politician as a “terrorist incident”
Michael Novakhov’s favorite articles on InoreaderUK Police are describing the murder of a politician as a “terrorist incident”posted at 14:00:26 UTC by BBC World Service via NewshourFollowing the murder of the Conservative MP Sir David Amess, two other MPs, Joanna Cherry from the SNP and Rupa Huq from the Labour party, tell us about threats they have…
 

Honey-Trapping Consumer Guides and other useful stories: US Treasury Department Puts Cryto Industry On Alert Over Rising Ransomware Attacks | US vows to pay relatives of Afghans killed in drone strike | Deputy killed, two others injured in Houston ‘ambush’: officials
Michael Novakhov’s favorite articles on Inoreader | Post LinkHoney-Trapping Consumer Guides and other useful stories: US Treasury Department Puts Cryto Industry On Alert Over Rising Ransomware Attacks | US vows to pay relatives of Afghans killed in drone strike | Deputy killed, two others injured in Houston ‘ambush’: officials Michael Novakhov retweeted:…
 

Former #PoliceChief charged in #CapitolRiot requests to defend himself in order to expose ‘#Corruption’ of #FBI – The FBI News Review from Michael Novakhov
 FBI – Post Linkfrom Michael Novakhov on Inoreader Impeachment: American Crime Story Episode 6 recap: Man Handled – Show Snobposted at 10:15:58 UTC via “FBI and wrongful convictions” – Google NewsImpeachment: American Crime Story Episode 6 recap: Man Handled  Show SnobWhat happens if Brian Laundrie isn’t found in the coming weeks – KESQposted at 09:57:44…
 

Russia, US mull fresh Putin-Biden meeting | Former NYPD cop pleads guilty to running international drug trafficking ring | Top cybersecurity stories | DOJ Reviewing Decision Not to Prosecute Agents in Nassar Case | Jan. 6 panel moves against Steve Bannon, sets contempt vote | Jan. 6 panel flexes its muscle
Former NYPD cop who beat suspect in 2010 pleads guilty to running international drug trafficking ring https://t.co/VD3lhZsqSI— Michael Novakhov (@mikenov) October 15, 2021 -Post LinkRussia, US mull fresh Putin-Biden meeting | Former NYPD cop pleads guilty to running international drug trafficking ring | Top cybersecurity stories | DOJ Reviewing Decision…
 

Rep. Adam Schiff recalls ‘painful’ Robert Mueller testimony | General Promises US ‘Surge’ Against Foreign Cyberattacks | Nations reveal ransomware pain at US-led summit | WHO announces committee to probe COVID-19 pandemic origins
Robert M. Brzenchek: Thanks for having me, Wes. As you know, in this world, there are increasingly capable hackers that are funded by nation-states such as China and Russia and massive spending in the United States on the internet of things (IoT) and 5G. We have advanced sentinels. We have data centers that will be everywhere. However, we can’t catch…
 

White House schedules a global ransomware summit WITHOUT Russia or China | Russia Ready To Communicate Directly With NATO – Putin | Spain evacuates 160 more Afghans via Pakistan
Michael Novakhov’s favorite articles on Inoreader | Post LinkWhite House schedules a global ransomware summit WITHOUT Russia or Chinaposted at 13:55:53 UTC via Russia News plus GRU, Hacking and Trump Probe Updates | Mail Online’We are having active discussions with the Russians, but in this particular forum they were not invited to participate,’ said…
 

UK security forces: Russia stole Oxford jab blueprint | EU Leaders Gather In Ukraine For Summit In Shadow Of Russia | Ukraine calls on US and Germany to impose sanctions on Russia’s Gazprom
4:25 AM 10/12/2021 – Post Link UK security forces: Russia stole Oxford jab blueprint | EU Leaders Gather In Ukraine For Summit In Shadow Of Russia | Ukraine calls on US and Germany to impose sanctions on Russia’s GazpromMichael Novakhov’s favorite articles on InoreaderUK security forces: Russia stole Oxford jab blueprint | United Kingdom | WION News…
 

#GayNews: Superman comes out as bisexual: DC Comics reveals woke superhero son of Clark Kent & Lois Lane will start a romance with a male best friend – just two months after company announced Batman sidekick Robin is also bi …
Post Link – 1:54 PM 10/11/2021 – Tweets by ‎@mikenovMichael Novakhov@mikenovwoke meaning – Google Search https://shar.es/aWCxMA  23m Michael Novakhov@mikenov#GayNews Superman comes out as bisexual: DC Comics reveals woke superhero son of Clark Kent & Lois Lane will start a romance with a male best friend – just two months after company announced…
 

10:17 AM 10/11/2021 – FBI: Navy Nuclear Engineer, Wife Attempted Espionage | Researchers Warn Of Ransomware Outfit Hitting Health Giants | Report details Trump’s all-out bid to undo election loss | Top Russian officials named in Pandora Papers
The News And Times Network  #JOSSICA: IJ #OpenSource #StrategicIntelligence #Counterintelligence #Analysis #News #Times #TNT https://t.co/Ua2bBpRAnt #Security #FBI #FBINews #US #ODNI #CIA #DOJ FBI: Navy Nuclear Engineer, Wife Attempted Espionage – GS https://t.co/zrZnsGU693 https://t.co/8XPAjY0nUe pic.twitter.com/NiD1vVNnIW— Michael Novakhov (@mikenov)…
 

8:03 AM 10/10/2021 – Michael Novakhov @mikenov: #JOSSICA: International Journal for the #OpenSource #StrategicIntelligence #Counterintelligence #Analysis #News #Times #TNT http://thenewsandtimes.blogspot.com #Security #FBI #FBINews #US #ODNI #CIA #DOJ #Russia #USRUSSIA #Psychoanalysis Of #IntelligenceOperations #NewAbwehrHypothesis #Psychohistory #History
 Tweets by ‎@mikenov – Post Link – 8:03 AM 10/10/2021 Michael Novakhov Retweeted𝐉𝐨𝐫𝐝𝐚𝐧@aka_dpuDeeply saddened by the tragic news of a plane crash in #Russia that resulted in 16 parachutists losing their lives.My heart felt condolences to the bereaved families and prayers for the injured for their speedy recovery. Deepest sympathy. 1h Michael Novakhov@mikenov#JOSSICA:…
 

1:05 PM 10/9/2021 – Selected Headlines | Criticism of the #USIntelligence | Havana Syndrome | Financial aid to Havana Syndrome victims by Biden government | Turkey is Becoming a Problem for NATO—the U.S. Should Pay Attention | Facebook is ‘biased against facts’, says Nobel prize winner | Supreme Court to Hear State Secrets Case on FBI Surveillance | Capitol police whistleblower claims leaders lied to Congress about Jan. 6 and mishandled evidence
Criticism of the #USIntelligence – Google Search shar.es/aWCrucPost Link – 1:05 PM 10/9/2021Michael Novakhov’s favorite articles on InoreaderFBI Reform: Supreme Court to Hear State Secrets Case on FBI Surveillance – Lawfareposted at 15:18:01 UTC by Admin via The FBI News Review from Michael_Novakhov (11 sites)Supreme Court to Hear State Secrets Case…
 

6:27 AM 10/9/2021 – “ODNI celebrates #PrideMonth and our diverse workforce.” – Tweets Review
 Tweets by ‎@mikenov – Post Link – 6:27 AM 10/9/2021 Michael Novakhov RetweetedOffice of the DNI✔@ODNIgovODNI celebrates #PrideMonth and our diverse workforce. Jun 1, 2018  Michael Novakhov RetweetedOffice of the DNI✔@ODNIgovThank you, DNI Coats and PDDNI Gordon, for your leadership and service to our country. Aug 15, 2019 Michael Novakhov@mikenov#News…
 

5:54 AM 10/9/2021 – Russian hackers attacking US government websites steal counter-intelligence and sanctions policy data – Selected Articles Review
The News And Times NetworkPost Link – 5:54 AM 10/9/2021 Russian hackers attacking US government websites steal counter-intelligence and sanctions policy dataSaturday October 9th, 2021 at 5:39 AMPositively Scottish1 ShareCyber ​​attacks on US government websites have received wide publicity. United States officials blame the Russian Foreign Intelligence…
 

Videos: Nobel Peace Prize: Russian, Philippine journalists – 10:51 AM 10/8/2021
Michael Novakhov’s favorite articles on Inoreader – 10:51 AM 10/8/2021 – Post Link1. VIDEO NEWS from Michael_Novakhov (74 sites): AssociatedPress’s YouTube Videos: Nobel Peace Prize: Russian, Philippine journalistsposted at 12:54:17 UTC by AssociatedPress via 1. Brooklyn Radio and Video from Michael_Novakhov (12 sites)From: AssociatedPressDuration: 02:00Journalists…
 

Новая Газета ✔ @novaya_gazeta: Муратов посвятил свою Нобелевскую премию мира всем погибшим журналистам нашей газеты – 10:07 AM 10/8/2021
 #BreakingNews #News #Times #TNT http://thenewsandtimes.blogspot.com #Security #FBI #FBINews #US #ODNI #CIA #DOJ #Psychoanalysis Of #IntelligenceOperations #OSSICA #NewAbwehrHypothesis #Psychohistory #History  Tweets by ‎@mikenov | Post Link – 10:07 AM 10/8/2021 Michael Novakhov RetweetedНовая Газета✔@novaya_gazetaМуратов посвятил свою Нобелевскую премию…
 

7:23 AM 10/6/2021 – Selected Headlines Review: #Lapid to visit #Washington next week to meet with #Blinken | #News #Times #TNT #Security #FBI #FBINews #US #ODNI #CIA #DOJ #Psychoanalysis Of #IntelligenceOperations #OSSICA F.B.I. Raids N.Y.P.D. Sergeants’ Union Office, Prompting Leader of the union president, Edward D. Mullins to Quit
#News #Times #TNT https://t.co/Ua2bBpzYYT #Security #FBI #FBINews #US #ODNI #CIA #DOJ #Psychoanalysis Of #IntelligenceOperations #OSSICA F.B.I. Raids N.Y.P.D. Sergeants’ Union Office, Prompting Leader of the union president, Edward D. Mullins to Quit https://t.co/XnfF2bzmOt— Michael Novakhov (@mikenov) October 6, 2021   The News And Times NetworkSelected…
 

Selected Articles Review: #OTD Oct 4,1985 #FBI agent #Robert_Hanssen volunteers to spy via letter to #KGB officer #Victor_Cherkashin, who also handled #Aldrich_Ames.
Post LinkMichael Novakhov retweeted: #OTD Oct 4,1985 #FBI agent #Robert_Hanssen volunteers to spy via letter to #KGB officer #Victor_Cherkashin, who also handled #Aldrich_Ames.posted on Oct 04 2021 10:21:23 UTC by admin via Michael Novakhov – Shared News and Tweets – michaelnovakhov-sharednewslinks.net – The News And TimesMichael Novakhov retweeted:#OTD Oct…
 

M.N.: “Pathognomonic” means HIGHLY INDICATIVE (FEATURE or PART, etc.) | @drmaypole: #Pathognomonic – one of my favorite terms in #medicine – describes a sign or finding incontrovertibly (or w/ at least high specificity) tied to a particular #disease . (From the Greek: ‘pathos’ or disease, ‘gnomon’, indicator) #diagnosis
 Tweets by ‎@mikenov | Post Link – 1:14 PM 10/4/2021 Michael Novakhov Retweetedjackmaypole@drmaypole#Pathognomonic -one of my favorite terms in #medicine-describes a sign or finding incontrovertibly (or w/ at least high specificity) tied to a particular #disease . (From the Greek: ‘pathos’ or disease, ‘gnomon’, indicator) #diagnosis #graphic-medicine…
 

#New Abwehr” remains a Hypothesis. It was formulated on the basis of the Hapsburg Croup report in Mueller Investigation, which provided the third (and defining, “pathognomonic”) criterion (logical “leg”): historical AUSTRIA-PHOBIA …
“New Abwehr” remains a Hypothesis. It was formulated on the basis of the Hapsburg Croup report in Mueller Investigation, which provided the third (and defining, “pathognomonic”) criterion (third logical “leg” to stand on): the historical German AUSTRIA-PHOBIA which in combination with the other two may be “DIAGNOSTIC”. The other two criteria are: ANTISEMITISM…
 
Categories
The News And Times Blog

8:59 AM 10/17/2021 – Tweets Review: @MavkaSlavka Putin is sending his constituents into a Covid nightmare. Sputnik has come crashing down to earth.

 Tweets 

  1.  Michael Novakhov Retweeted

    Putin is sending his constituents into a Covid nightmare. Sputnik has come crashing down to earth.

  1.  Michael Novakhov Retweeted

    State-By-State Look at America’s Richest Families

    •  

  2.  Michael Novakhov Retweeted

    Thousands in Puerto Rico are protesting the imposed US government privatization of the electricity grid that’s left unprecedented outages & billing increases since June. The large scale protest demands the cancellation of the contract with LUMA. 💪🏼🔥

    Embedded video

    •  

  3.  Michael Novakhov Retweeted

    Who thinks we should host a @TwitterSpaces this week?

    If so, what topics/questions would you like us to answer?

    View image on Twitter

    •  

  4.  Michael Novakhov Retweeted

    Liebe Leute! Ich freue mich wahnsinnig, dass ich ab jetzt die wöchentliche Kolumne „Kiew Calling“ über meine Erfahrungen in Kiew für die @berlinerzeitung am Wochenende schreiben darf. Würde mich total freuen, wenn ihr einen Blick auf die erste Folge werft! https://www.berliner-zeitung.de/wochenende/kiew-calling-die-hauptstadt-der-ukraine-ist-mehr-also-nur-das-zweite-berlin-li.188701 

    •  

  5.  Michael Novakhov Retweeted

    Глава МЧС Вадим Синявский: При введении ЧП пожарные с оружием в руках будут защищать стратегические объекты и подавлять беспорядки.

    View image on Twitter

    •